Britney Spears’ ex-manager sues Christian publisher: libel, defamation charges threaten the religious
Spears’ ex-manager Sam Lutfi amended his complaint for libel and defamation damages to include the publisher of her mother’s book Through the Storm, A Real Story of Fame and Family in a Tabloid World, last Friday according to new filings at a Los Angeles County courthouse.
The move came after Lynne Spears filed an appeal on Aug. 11, 2009 against a judge’s earlier decision to uphold Lutfi’s case. In short, the judge ruled that it was uncontested that Lynne had published a book, and that testimony namely by Lutfi, Adnan Ghalib, Britney’s ex-boyfriend, and Felipe Texeira, a paparazzo, established a legal basis to uphold Lutfi’s suit.
Thomas Nelson, Inc. is a publisher and purveyor of Christian books such as bibles and tales of faith and praying such as those offered in Lynne’s Through the Storm. God and Christianity, are no strangers to the company’s web pages. The company has international affiliation but Lutfi’s suit is specific to the corporation located in the bible belt at Nashville, Tennessee.
Meanwhile, in the suit that Lynne appealed, the judge in Los Angeles had weighed whether Lutfi had enough of a suit to constitute libel and defamation in making his decision.
“Lynne Spears – both in the book and her declaration (first submitted in Feb. 2008 to secure a restraining order against Lutfi from Britney) submitted herewith – asserts that Lutfi and Ghalib said and did certain things which Lutfi and Ghalib deny doing. This operates to establish the elements of falsity required for the claims, and the contradiction also logically that Spears acted with a reckless disregard for the truth as she reported statements which the alleged speakers deny ever making,” says the judge in a July 29, 2009 minutes order.
The judge further determined that Lutfi had made a case for both libel and defamation. Therefore the judge dismissed Lynne’s motion from June based on an Anti-SLAPP motion in its entirety.
The next hearing is Oct. 1 according to the online case summary. Lutfi’s motion against Lynne is part of an overall suit naming Britney, a conservatee, her father Jamie Spears her co-conservator along with Andrew Wallet, and Lynne claiming libel, defamation, battery, intentional infliction of emotional distress and breach of contract. He filed the suit in Feb. 2009 just days after Jamie Spears requested a judge to order temporary restraining orders against Lutfi, Ghalib and Jon Earley, an attorney, claiming their conspiracy to derail the conservatorship.
Pic Source: Kill the Lights
Related court documents: